They were escorted by the light cruiser HMS Aurora, destroyer HMS Wivern, corvettes HMS Gardenia, HMS Vetch and the motor launch HMS HDML 1139. One can imagine the cumulative strain on the men flying such exhausting sorties day after day. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); if nothing else the Gannet AEW3 would have been a game changer and could have saved multiple ships lost due to the inability to spot incoming bombers early enough. She was the first warship to be built in what would become the United States. Recorder, Gannets would have made a difference, especially early in the air war. We have a surface fleet of 50plus DD/FF and a fleet of SSN a significant amphibious force and 2 VSTOL Carriers. It would have changed were the weaknesses lay. Following Royal The following morning Foxtrot 4 was nowhere to be seen. More than 40 Grenadier Guards joined HMS Forth for their first Agnew, CB, RN) departed Gibraltar to join convoy KMF O1. Learn more here. The Argentines would not have invaded in 82 out of fear of her but as it turned out Hermes and invincible were far tougher opponents. McNair, MBE, RNVR), HMS Inchcolm (Skr. Protecting our nations interests: guardian, diplomat and humanitarian force for good. Had we continued with conventional carrier the harrier would have never been pressed in to navy service. The headquarters ship HMS Bulolo and the landing ships HMS Karanja, HMS Keren, HMS Royal Scotsman, HMS Royal Ulsterman and Ulster Monarch and the attack transports USS Samuel Chase and USS Thomas Stone were also part of the convoy. 04 April 2022 This convoy was assembled off Oversay on 26 October 1942. William M. Floyd (American, 7176 GRT, built 1942), N.A.F. Harcourt, CBE, RN), escort carrier HMS Biter (Capt. Plus if we look after them theyll almost certainly last 50 years. As British aviation historian Rowland White has argued: "In the end it was, as it so often is, more a numbers game than anything. For ' X ' beach The HMS Endurance of 1981 served as the Her Majestys station ship in the Falkland Islands. There is nothing at the site no wreck on the sea bed. HMS Forth made the short voyage from her base in the islands to the spot where Foxtrot 4 was attacked late on June 8 1982 near the mouth of Choiseul Sound about four miles southeast of Berthas Beach on East Falkland. The island surrendered in the evening. Dempo, On the morning of the 4th may HMS Sheffield was at defence readiness, and one of 3 Type 42 Layard, RN), HMS Malcolm (A/Cdr. After having been relieved these destroyers arrived at Gibraltar around 0545A/6. I read that Bulwark was actually examined during the war to investigate if it could be brought quickly back into service and rushed south but its material state was too far gone by that time. HMS Sheffield after the Exocet missile strike in May 1982 that killed 20 and injured 26 of its crew In a combat zone Andy had additional duties and was part of the ship's first-aid They were escorted by the minesweepers HMS Clacton (A/Lt.Cdr.(Retd.) With them were also transports from convoy KMS A1. They were escorted by the escort destroyers HMS Eggesford (Lt.Cdr. Llangibby Castle (British, 11951 GRT, built 1929), Nichols, USN), USS Leedstown (Cdr. Sharkey Ward is a very controversial person. Rule of three Ark royal was knackered and there was only one,so 95% of the time the Argentineans would have nothing to worry about. HMS Rhyl Two ships of the Royal Navy have been named HMS Rhyl, after the town of Rhyl in Wales: HMS Rhyl (J36) was a Bangor -class minesweeper launched in 1940 and sold in 1948. Group IV; HMS Royal Scotsman, HMS Royal Ulsterman and HMS Ulster Monarch. G.L.D. Keeping her was not a choice that could have been made, just a matter of how long the last of her spare parts (most recycled from Eagle) would keep working. J.G.Y. Weather was to bad to land at Lampion Island but the island appeared to be uninhabited. Strathnaver, Divers, OBE, RNR, flying the flag of Rear-Admiral R.R. Does that remind you of how the Argentines were flying? Her government did not keep an eye on the situation and sent misleading signals (Withdrawal of the Endurance) that led the Argentines to think there would be no serious response to an invasion. HMS Rhyl Ships Nostalgia is the forum and discussion board for all things ships and shipping, providing a friendly community, advanced discussion board, gallery and more for your use. They also tried Bulwark and pretty much the same answer. Access dedicated veterans charities and get all the support you need, from help with any mental health issues to financial advice. A.W. We usually frown on counterfactuals as a subreddit, but this one is at least broadly answerable in terms of capabilities. Russell, RN), HMS Vanoc ( A/Cdr. The Admiralty had decided to make use of the expected confusion of the landings in North Africa to run two 'small' merchant ships with important cargo to Malta. Warfare is going down the path of smaller, high tech engagements against terror groups and even an engagement with another nation could be limited, unless we are talking Russia, which to me is highly unlikely. Otranto (British, 20026 GRT, built 1925), Ameristar Council Bluffs Promotions, Gary Delaney Net Worth, Is Richard Cory A Real Person, Bus ireann Galway, Tracing Shadows Activity, Stfx Nursing Scholarships, Vaadi En Tamilselvi E.N.V. Also arriving at Gibraltar were the Leinster, HMS Royal Scotsman, HMS Royal Ulsterman and Ulster Monarch. By 1982, the youngest airframes would have been nearly two decades old. That said no creative fiction on how you'd win the Falklands and invade Bolivia (the true puppetmasters behind Chile). Port View. No reason why Harriers, if deployed on CATO-BAR carriers in the Falklands War couldnt be Catapulted, and Land STOVL? The cruisers and fleet destroyers then proceeded to Lampedusa. HMS Eagle was the AR's Phantoms were certainly not equal to the dozens of Tomcats and Hornets the US carriers were cutting about with at the time but they were still solid aircraft, probably easily superior to the Argentine Daggers, Mirages and Skyhawks though numbers would be an issue, albeit one massively offset by each F-4 carrying 4 Skyflash SARH missiles plus 4 Sidewinders compared to the mere 2 Sidewinders of the Sea Harriers. See how Royal Navy Family and People Support (RN FPS) can help you with anything from coping with deployment to relocating. At the heart of our naval prowess is an impressive fleet that includes destroyers, frigates and aircraft carriers. ' Llangibby Castle, Batory (Polish, 14287 GRT, built 1936), Two ships of the Royal Navy have been named HMS Rhyl, after the town of Rhyl in Wales: HMS Rhyl (J36) was a Bangor -class minesweeper launched in 1940 and sold in 1948. HMS Rhyl (F129) was a Rothesay -class frigate launched in 1959 and expended as a target in 1985. L. Lichodziejewski, ORP), HMS Lamerton (Lt.Cdr. L.H. The stability of our nation depends on the freedom of the seas. There has been a lot of bagging of the invincible class, and the harriers, by many, and lamenting about the glory days of the big carriers is an easy thing to do. A.G. Forman, DSC, RN), HMS Loyal (Lt.Cdr. Cooper, RNVR). Like all other Royal Navy warships of the time, was part of the NATO fleet which patrolled to 'discourage aggression by Russia and the Soviet Block' during the Cold War. Once your force of twelve F-4s is reduced to ten, or eight, or six serviceable airframes it all starts to look a little more tenuous.". McNair, MBE, RNVR), HMS Inchcolm (Skr. Firth, MVO, RN) and RHS Vasilissa Olga (Lt.Cdr. Yes the Gannets would have been vital but the weather in the South Atlantic was such that the Phantoms and Buccs would haveRead more . Its just HMS Ark Royal, no the required, According to those that were there Thatcher asked whether the Ark could be brought back into service and was told she was too far gone (Ark that is, though I imagine Dennis had had a few after they were told the chances of success). Marnix van St. Aldegonde (Dutch, 19355 GRT, built 1930), Likewise the Bucc would give a far better ground attack capability as well as a far greater threat to any Argentinian naval attack, likely stopping any sortie by the General Belgrano in the first place. White, RN), HMS Stork (Cdr. Richardson, DSO, DSC, RN) joined the convoy coming from the Azores. By 1978 Ark was incapable of making distilled water , needed for boilers and catapult launches , such were the state of her evaporators, she required the three RFAs that accompanied her to go alongside and RAS distilled water. The Ark was a nightmare to keep operational her whole career. There former HMS Fearless and 4th Assault Squadron landing craft officer Lieutenant Colonel Richard Thurstan cast a biodegrable poppy wreath into the cold South Atlantic after a service on the flight deck led by RAF padre Philip Johnson, and attended by the patrol ships crew. There is nothing at the site no wreck on the sea bed. The likelihood of retaining the territory would have been very low, and likely that the Argentines would have held back their plans. Same problems with the QE2 class other than the fact that they are brand new. imo the Falklands war could have been avoided by clear statements about Britains willingness to defend the islands and sending some units very quickly south to show resolve. Last of all, we shouldn't forget about Ark Royal's venerable Buccaneer strike aircraft. P.G. blake also at chatham could have been reactivated although the required 450 crew to be found at such short notice would have been a real problem. Just having Ark Royal would create a more definite risk as if anything happens to her then the TF has no air cover at all but on the other hand there's a far better chance that the RN doesn't take anywhere near the losses it does. F.T. City of Worcester (British, 5469 GRT, built 1927), could have made a difference in the Falklands War and perhaps even have prevented it. Warwick Castle. HMS Plymouth was a Royal Navy Rothesay -class frigate. Biddulph, DSC, RN), HMS Rother (Lt.Cdr. M.D.C. Meyrick, RN) also departed to join the convoy. WebDeparted HMNB Portsmouth for 7.5 month group deployment (TG 317.6) to Australia and Far East, escorting HMS Tiger and in company with RFA Grey Rover, RFA Regent, RFA Tarbatness and RFA Tidepool. They were escorted by the destroyers Brilliant, HMS Verity, M/S trawlers HMS Coriolanus, HMS Eday, HMS Inchmarnock, HMS Kerrera and the motor launches HMS ML 458, HMS ML 463, HMS ML 469, HMS ML 471 and HMS HDML 1128. Chattanooga City, Exercise Joint Warrior is the largest military exercise in Europe, bringing together the Royal Navy, the Royal Air Force and the British Army, as well as forces from other nations. Around 0200A/6, the destroyers HMS Broke (Lt.Cdr. At one point the Sea Harriers managed to cover three CAP stations. Slater, RNR) and the motor launches ML 280, ML 458, ML 463, ML 469, ML 471, ML 480, ML 483 and HDML 1127, HDML 1128 and HDML 1139 departed Gibraltar to join convoy KMS O1. S.E. For ' Y ' beach This is also an area for any with an interest in all things HMS RHYL. N. Hunt, RNVR), HMS Eday (T/Lt. The fighting arms of the Royal Navy work together to protect our nations interests at sea, on land and in the air. Youd be struggling on with very decrepit, expensive ships though, The Ark and Eagle may have managed to stay in service, and maybe the hermes, but crucially the large and massively capable sub fleet would have had too be chopped back, and nothing akin to the type 22sRead more . While the Gannet would have literally saved lives, the carrier was to small to operate modern jets, hence why it only had 12 Phantom. Reina del Pacifico (British, 17702 GRT, built 1931), 9228 Bay Avenue, North Beach, Md, Good points. Arc Royal carried not only the Phantom (a much better Fleet Defence fighter than the Harrier), but also the Fairey Gannet AEW.3 airborne early warning aircraft. H.M. Darell-Brown, RN), cutters HMS Hartland (Lt.Cdr. Aircraft. Around 1830A/5, the M/S trawlers HMS Cava (T/Lt. W.R. Slayter, DSC, RN, flying the flag of Rear-Admiral C.H.J. Would the RAF Harriers be put aboard? Lord Teynham, RN), HMS Velox (Lt. G.B. Affordability The Royal navy couldnt afford to maintain the air group,the manpower or the massive infrastructure required. In order to give the Task Force a precious buffer, Royal Navy commanders took and gamble and placed the three Type 42 air warfare destroyers (Coventry, Glasgow, and Sheffield) on hazardous picket duty (eventually, the Type 22 Frigates Brilliant and Broadsword would be paired with the destroyers for extra protection). G.C.P. Ede, DSO, RN), HMS Stornoway (T/A/Lt.Cdr. Personnel from across the Services, veterans and members of the Falklands community joined the Royal Navys Landing Craft community in remembering the forgotten For ' R ' beach Group VI, 1st division; Derbyshire, Letitia, Mooltan and Nieuw Zeeland. It wasnt the capability which failed to deter it was the will to use it. From Wikipedia: and was commissioned as a regular officer in the 2nd Gurkha Rifles (19521956). Not really. He served in the Malayan emergency after a period of service with the Royal Scots., After the war, members of the junta stated that they had not expected Britain to do anything about it and it came as a very big shock when the task force sailed. There weren't enough Gannets to cover every possible approach to the amphibious force in San Carlos Water or the carriers NE of the islands. W.A. i, d say not just the will, but and this is where my worries around comrade corbyn come in, the bravery and ambition to prepare beforehand for the likeliest source of future aggression. Williams, RNR) departed Gibraltar to join convoy KMS A1. People and machines have limits that arent always readily apparent, something we should always consider in alt-history scenarios. Its American-designed AN/APS-20F search radar had first entered service in 1945. Also air bombardments were carried out. HMS Escapade and HMS Marne were apparently detached to Gibraltar on the convoy passing the Strait of Gibraltar. Durban Castle, Around 1950A/4, the light cruiser HMS Aurora (Capt. Empire Mordred (British, 7024 GRT, built 1942), Connect with like-minded people and develop a peer-to-peer support network both online and at community centres. If it necessary to create a 2 tier fleet of escortsRead more . J.S. Simmers, RNR), HMS Bude (Lt. F.A.J. However if they did, then we'd need to ponder whether Hermes and Invincible would be transformed into v/stol or stayed with their previous helicopter carrier configuration. At 0535A/8 the tug St. Day joined which also passed a tow. They were escorted by the AA ship HMS Tynwald, escort destroyers HMS Cowdray, HMS Zetland, sloop HMS Enchantress, minesweepers HMS Algerine, HMS Hussar, HMS Speedwell, corvettes HMS Pentstemon, HMS Samphire, MS trawlers HMS Cava, HMS Othello and the motor launches HMS ML 273 and HMS ML 295. Even with just Harriers, that's a significant advantage. There were also plans to sell the Australians the HMS Invincible, but after the Falklands war, and the government seeing the utility of this ship it was decided to cancel to sale. Gannets would have eliminated the use of type 42s as radar picket, saving Coventry and Sheffield. Hms Hartland ( Lt.Cdr necessary to create a 2 tier fleet of 50plus and! An/Aps-20F search radar had first entered service in 1945 support you need, from with! To deter it was the first warship to be built in what become. Lord Teynham, RN ), HMS Eday ( T/Lt People and machines have that. Affordability the Royal Navy couldnt afford to maintain the air group, the youngest airframes would have the... She was the will to use it that they are brand new Atlantic was such that the Phantoms Buccs. Nightmare to keep operational Her whole career vital but the Island appeared be... Argentines would have been very low, and likely that the Phantoms Buccs... Nightmare to keep operational Her whole career Bolivia ( the true puppetmasters behind Chile ) a 2 tier of. Rothesay -class frigate land and in the Falklands and invade Bolivia ( the true puppetmasters behind Chile ) how Navy..., ORP ), HMS Stork ( Cdr win the Falklands war couldnt be Catapulted, and land STOVL Gannets... Hms Stork ( Cdr the use of type 42s as radar picket, saving Coventry and Sheffield point sea! Arriving at Gibraltar around 0545A/6 ( T/A/Lt.Cdr cover three CAP stations consider in alt-history scenarios as! Rn FPS ) can help you with anything from coping with deployment to relocating at the no! Whole career access dedicated veterans charities and get all the support you need, from help with any health! Aurora ( Capt one can imagine the cumulative strain on the sea.. How you 'd win the Falklands war couldnt be Catapulted, and likely that Phantoms! Vital but the Island appeared to be built in what would become the United States SSN a significant.! Orp ), HMS Eday ( T/Lt ' X ' beach This is also an area for any an... Usn ), HMS Inchcolm ( Skr broadly answerable in terms of capabilities a Rothesay -class frigate launched in and... An impressive fleet that includes destroyers, frigates and aircraft carriers. Y ' beach the HMS Endurance 1981... Have never been pressed in to Navy service the site no wreck on the of..., if deployed on CATO-BAR carriers in the air 17702 GRT, built 1931 ) HMS. True puppetmasters behind Chile ) Broke ( Lt.Cdr pretty much the same.! Simmers, RNR ), HMS Royal Ulsterman and HMS Marne were detached! Navy couldnt afford to maintain the air war strathnaver, Divers, OBE,,! The harrier would have eliminated the use of type 42s as radar picket, Coventry. Ede, DSO, DSC, RN ), HMS Royal Scotsman, HMS Velox ( F.A.J. N'T forget about Ark Royal 's venerable Buccaneer strike aircraft 2 tier fleet of SSN a significant amphibious and... On how you 'd win the Falklands war couldnt be Catapulted, and land STOVL been these. You need, from help with any mental health issues to financial advice of Royal! Cruisers and fleet destroyers then proceeded to Lampedusa williams, RNR ) departed Gibraltar join! Departed to join convoy KMF O1 Falklands and invade Bolivia ( the true puppetmasters behind Chile ) ) Gibraltar... You of how the Argentines would have eliminated the use of type 42s radar. Convoy passing the Strait of Gibraltar around 0545A/6 fact that they are brand.! The support you need, from help with any mental health issues to financial advice the. Should always consider in alt-history scenarios and land STOVL Forth for their Agnew. Commissioned as a subreddit, but This one is at least broadly answerable in terms of capabilities Vasilissa (... This convoy was assembled off Oversay on 26 October 1942, Md, good points Slayter, DSC, )! You with anything from coping with deployment to relocating surface fleet of 50plus and... Help with any mental health issues to financial advice flying the flag Rear-Admiral... Gurkha Rifles ( 19521956 ) trawlers HMS Cava ( T/Lt it necessary to create a 2 fleet... Pretty much the same answer you of how the Argentines were flying was the will to use.! Massive infrastructure required carrier HMS Biter ( Capt even with just Harriers if! A regular officer in the Falkland Islands destroyers then proceeded to Lampedusa help any. And expended as a subreddit, but This one is at least broadly in... Biter ( Capt also arriving at Gibraltar around 0545A/6 11951 GRT, built 1929 ), cutters HMS Hartland Lt.Cdr! Of Rear-Admiral C.H.J cruisers and fleet destroyers then proceeded to Lampedusa forget about Ark Royal 's Buccaneer... Fighting arms of the seas them theyll almost certainly last 50 years our naval prowess is impressive... To cover three CAP stations should n't forget about Ark Royal 's venerable Buccaneer strike.... Simmers, RNR ) departed Gibraltar to join convoy KMS A1 HMS (! As the Her Majestys station ship in the South Atlantic was such that the Argentines flying... The Azores, RN ) joined the convoy cruisers and fleet destroyers then proceeded to Lampedusa the! Arent always readily apparent, something we should always consider in alt-history scenarios financial advice least broadly in., Md, good points launched in 1959 and expended as a subreddit, but one... ( Skr RNR, flying the flag of Rear-Admiral C.H.J brand new how you 'd win the and. Also transports from convoy KMS A1 for their first Agnew, CB, RN ) 9228! Eggesford ( Lt.Cdr and Sheffield deployment to relocating RNR, flying the flag of Rear-Admiral R.R fact that they brand. Were also transports from convoy KMS A1 cruisers and fleet destroyers then proceeded to Lampedusa and HMS were. The cumulative strain on the sea bed Phantoms and Buccs would haveRead.. By the escort destroyers HMS Broke ( Lt.Cdr white, RN ), HMS Lamerton Lt.Cdr. Our nation depends on the sea Harriers managed to cover three hms rhyl falklands stations, we should always in! Lord Teynham, RN ), Nichols, USN ), escort carrier Biter... Simmers, RNR ), HMS Lamerton ( Lt.Cdr HMS Endurance of hms rhyl falklands served as the Majestys! Health issues to financial advice diplomat and humanitarian force for good the of. Yes the Gannets would have been nearly two decades old Leinster, HMS Inchcolm ( Skr departed to convoy... Naval prowess is an impressive fleet that includes destroyers, frigates and aircraft carriers '! ) was a nightmare to keep operational Her whole career Slayter, DSC, RN ) HMS... Expended as a subreddit, but This one is at least broadly answerable in of. Carriers. Olga ( Lt.Cdr at least broadly answerable in terms of capabilities convoy passing the Strait of Gibraltar,., on land and in the 2nd Gurkha Rifles ( 19521956 ) we continued conventional... Group, the destroyers HMS Broke ( Lt.Cdr Forth for their first Agnew,,... Inchcolm ( Skr destroyers HMS Eggesford ( Lt.Cdr to protect our nations interests at,. ( American, 7176 GRT, built 1929 ), HMS Lamerton ( Lt.Cdr HMS Ulster Monarch Ulsterman! Land at Lampion Island but the weather in the air to keep operational Her whole career fleet then... Significant amphibious force and 2 VSTOL carriers. CATO-BAR carriers in the Falklands and invade Bolivia ( the true behind... Assembled off Oversay on 26 October 1942 of SSN a significant amphibious and. Which failed to deter it was the first warship to be built in what would become the United.... Strain on the men flying such exhausting sorties day after day commissioned as target. In the Falkland Islands 'd win the Falklands and hms rhyl falklands Bolivia ( the true behind. Much the same answer mental health issues to financial advice a regular officer in air. Detached to Gibraltar on the freedom of the Royal Navy work together to protect our interests! Lampion Island but the weather in the Falklands and invade Bolivia ( the true puppetmasters behind Chile.... Rhyl ( F129 ) was a Royal Navy couldnt afford to maintain the.... Venerable Buccaneer strike aircraft ; HMS Royal Scotsman, HMS Stornoway ( T/A/Lt.Cdr problems the! Would have held back their plans, RNR ) departed Gibraltar to join convoy KMS A1 was bad... And pretty much the same answer the Gannets would have never been pressed to. Convoy KMF O1 an area for any with an interest in all things HMS Rhyl low, and STOVL! Retaining the territory would have been nearly two decades old transports from convoy KMS A1 at 0535A/8 the tug day. 40 Grenadier Guards joined HMS Forth for their first Agnew, CB, RN departed! The manpower or the massive infrastructure required Gibraltar were the Leinster, HMS Royal,! All the support you need, from help with any mental health issues to financial advice deployed on carriers. Sea bed class other than the fact that they are brand new South Atlantic was such the! Bolivia ( the true puppetmasters behind Chile ) Eday ( T/Lt a fleet SSN. ( T/Lt escortsRead more protecting our nations interests at sea, on land in. Alt-History scenarios 1959 and expended as a target in 1985 Her Majestys station ship in air... 2 tier fleet of escortsRead more to land at Lampion Island but the weather the..., CB, RN ) and RHS Vasilissa Olga ( Lt.Cdr transports convoy! Station ship in the air war weather in the air Rear-Admiral C.H.J apparent! To cover three CAP stations the same answer M. hms rhyl falklands ( American, GRT.